The Battle with the Bleeding Stains: My Experience with Primers

The Battle with the Bleeding Stains: My Experience with Primers
By Rob Grant - August 2, 2024

While painting isn't the biggest challenge in residential remodeling, it's one area where issues can arise, especially when it comes to dealing with different substrates. In my work with Grant Associates LLC, providing remodels and renovations in Weston, Wellesley, and Wayland, Massachusetts, I've found that the choice of primer can make or break the final outcome of a project. Even though I don't see this issue as frequently in my service areas, when it does occur, it becomes particularly apparent with various shades of whites and off-whites. The primer’s ability to block stains, smoke damage, pet damage, or wear and tear becomes critical. Over the years, I’ve tested numerous primers, including some of the most highly regarded ones, but I've found that many still fall short, particularly in their ability to prevent bleed-through.

The Initial Problem: Ineffective Stain Blocking

There are countless issues that come up during a renovation, but one of the biggest pains I've encountered is when primers fail to block stains properly. I've used well-known products like Benjamin Moore’s INSL-X and Sherwin Williams' water-based shellac primers, among others. Despite following the 24-hour dry time recommendation, I've experienced bleed-through on several occasions. This can be incredibly frustrating, especially when you've invested time and resources into what you hoped would be a foolproof solution.

Health Concerns and Product Efficacy

One major reason for choosing certain primers over others in projects is health and safety. Many of the effective stain-blocking primers require extensive personal protective equipment (PPE) and ventilation due to their strong fumes and harsh chemicals. While these products, often oil-based or shellac-based, have proven their worth in blocking stains, they also pose significant health risks and are cumbersome to work with, especially when using a paint sprayer. Shellac primers, which are alcohol-based, are made by dissolving natural shellac resin in ethanol. This mixture allows the primer to dry quickly and adhere effectively to a variety of surfaces, providing excellent stain-blocking properties. Both shellac and oil-based primers require meticulous cleaning with mineral spirits or other suitable solvents, making them less practical for extensive use with paint sprayers and more suited for brush applications. Despite these challenges, they are often the only products that can effectively prevent stains from bleeding through, particularly when dealing with severe damage.

The Ineffectiveness of Water-Based Primers

In my experience working on remodels, I’ve had very little success when it comes to stain blocking with any water-based primer. While these primers are better for health and easier to clean up, they often fail to prevent bleed-through on stained surfaces. In multiple instances, I’ve applied several coats of PVA primer or other basic primers over standard wall paint when changing colors, only to see stains reappear. This not only wastes the product but also poses health risks, as some water-based primers are not suitable for use in poorly ventilated areas. Spraying multiple coats of ineffective primers, even water-based ones, can be dangerous due to ventilation health risks. Always use what works!

The Question of Substrate Replacement

A common question is why not replace the stained substrate entirely. While this is sometimes necessary—such as in cases of persistent mold in a bathroom ceiling—it’s not always feasible. For instance, in rooms with smoke damage or pet residue, completely replacing the substrate can be impractical. In such cases, a full coat or spot treatment with shellac or oil-based primer is often the most effective solution. This approach has been particularly effective in the renovations and remodels I've completed in Massachusetts.

Real-World Examples

I’ve advised customers in Weston and Wellesley on the limitations of primers, but some still sought alternative contractors. In one instance, despite my warnings, a customer chose an unlicensed handyman who cleaned the ceiling, applied a good stain-blocking primer, and followed with quality ceiling paint. Despite these efforts, I watched mold regrow on the ceiling. While working on a different part of the home over several months, the mold reappeared, highlighting the need to remove and replace the substrate. Another customer stopped communicating with me due to similar issues, only to discover that the substrate was unsuitable for painting.

Preparation: Sanding and Cleaning

Proper preparation is essential for effective stain blocking, especially in the detailed carpentry and painting work I do with Grant Associates LLC. Before applying primer, I recommend sanding the surface lightly with any suitable sanding material to ensure good adhesion. Cleaning the surface thoroughly is also crucial, especially when dealing with pet stains and smoke residue. Using mineral spirits to clean these areas can help remove contaminants and provide a better surface for the primer to adhere to. This step can significantly enhance the primer's effectiveness in blocking stains and preventing bleed-through.

Successful Stain Blocking with Shellac and Oil-Based Primers

Through trial and error in my various projects over the years, I’ve found that shellac or oil-based primers are the most reliable for blocking stains. Whether dealing with smoke-damaged walls, pet stains, or other types of residue, these primers have consistently performed well. In particular, shellac products can be spot-sprayed to salvage wood and effectively block stains, even when other highly-rated primers have failed.

Want to learn more or discuss your next project? Visit the contact page on our website to get in touch!